The Indonesian government has approved a Presidential agreement to repatriate the five remaining members of the notorious "Bali Nine" to Australia, marking a significant shift in their life sentences. The decision effectively commutes their current punishment in Indonesian prisons, enabling their transfer to Australian custody.
On Saturday, November 23, 2024, Indonesia’s Minister of Law, Supratman Andi Agtas, confirmed the plan. The five Australians will serve indeterminate sentences in Australian prisons, although the duration remains under review. It is anticipated to be less severe than the life sentences without parole they are currently serving in Indonesia.
This bilateral agreement between Indonesia and Australia also includes a prisoner exchange arrangement, whereby Indonesian nationals in Australian prisons will be returned to their home country.
Broader Implications for Prisoner Transfers
In conjunction with the decision to repatriate the "Bali Five," Indonesia has also resolved to transfer Mary Jane Veloso, a Philippine national previously on death row for drug smuggling, to the Philippines. Veloso narrowly avoided execution in 2015 by agreeing to act as a state witness against a trafficking network. She will now serve her sentence in her home country.
The agreement for the Australians’ transfer reportedly stems from discussions between Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto during the APEC Summit in Lima, Peru.
Minister Supratman, quoted by *The Jakarta Post*, emphasized that the decision reflects humanitarian considerations: “This is the president’s discretion, but in principle, the President has agreed on humanitarian grounds.”
While details of the arrangement are still being negotiated, Supratman has insisted on mutual respect for Indonesia’s judicial process. “This is important to maintain good relationships with friendly nations. But it’s also in our interest because we have prisoners abroad,” he added.
Legal Challenges to the Repatriation Process
The unprecedented nature of the transfer poses significant legal and procedural challenges. Indonesia has no formal legislation governing prisoner transfers, which could complicate or delay the process.
International law expert Hikmahanto Juwana expressed concerns about the legal implications, warning against proceeding without a robust framework. “Proceeding with the transfer without a clear legal basis will tear our existing laws to shreds. Previous administrations have always reasoned that such transfers are impossible due to the lack of legal provisions. Yet, this administration seems to disregard that entirely,” he said.
Similarly, international relations expert Ahmad Rizky M. Umar highlighted the need for clarity and transparency: “If the prisoner transfer is part of a broader agenda, it must be communicated clearly, and the scheme itself must have a strong legal foundation.”
Potential Delays and Calls for Reform
Delays may also arise from parties seeking to clarify Indonesia’s stance on capital punishment and broader prisoner rights. Amnesty International’s Executive Director, Usman Hamid, has called for a reevaluation of Indonesia’s policies, urging the country to align with international human rights standards.
“Indonesia should abolish the death penalty or at least impose a moratorium. The current deal highlights the need for deeper reforms,” Hamid stated, emphasizing the importance of establishing consistent legal protocols for prisoner transfers.
France has also reportedly requested the repatriation of a French national imprisoned in Indonesia, further underscoring the need for clear policies to manage such exchanges.
Moving Forward
As discussions continue, the repatriation of the “Bali Five” and Mary Jane Veloso remains a sensitive and legally complex issue. While the agreements signify a willingness for international collaboration, the absence of comprehensive legal frameworks in Indonesia could hinder progress.
For now, both Australia and the Philippines are urged to respect Indonesia’s legal processes, while Indonesian authorities work to balance humanitarian considerations with adherence to domestic law.
You can add one right now!